Loss and gain

1 Comment » // May 24th, 2011

“The greatest loss of all, the loss of oneself, happens very quietly in the world as if it were nothing at all. No other loss occurs so quietly.”
Soren Kierkegaard

I saw this quote the other day in, of all places, an old episode of Men In Trees. It resonated with me so deeply that I had to share it. Here’s why: The cover of my book is a frog and I explain why in Chapter 1.

**

There is an analogy that is widely used in the study of cults. (You may have heard it used by environmentalists when they discuss global warming.) It is commonly called the Frog in Boiling Water scenario. It is such a widely known and used analogy in this field of study, that in fact, for a while, the cult recovery center Wellspring Retreat and Resource Center, in Albany, Ohio, used a frog as their corporate logo.

The analogy is based on scientific fact and goes like this: if you put a frog in a pot of room-temperature water on a stove and slowly turn up the heat under the pot, the frog will not register the slow and subtle change in temperature and, eventually, will boil to death without ever having realized it was in danger. However, if you first boil the water in the pot and then drop the frog into the boiling water, the frog will immediately sense the danger in the water temperature and jump out.

I haven’t even met you but I can say for sure that you’re just as smart as that frog, and if the water was already boiling when you approached a cult, you would jump out right away. If, on your first visit to a spiritual, political or business group, you were instructed to leave your spouse and give your young children away to be raised by their grandparents and marry someone from the group whom you barely knew and leave your home and quit your job to go and live in a remote wilderness lodge and work for no wages seven days a week, year round, all because a fat, blonde woman with an Austrian accent at the front of the room said that “God” was speaking to her in a voice only she could hear and it was He who said you should do these things, you, and every other person on the planet, would run screaming from the room and never, ever look back.

But that’s just the trouble. If it were that easy to spot thought-reform techniques being used on a group, gurus would go out of business faster than you can say, “Is it just me or is it a little warm in here?” At first, everything seems normal and comfortable, there at room temperature. The people are friendly, there’s an element of purposefulness and meaning that has perhaps been lacking in your life and you’re pleased to find a group of like-minded people with whom to explore spiritual (or political or business) questions and, besides, even medical doctors agree that learning to meditate is good for your physical and mental health. The woman teaching the class is charismatic and a little out there, but she is also a refreshing breath of air and she makes you feel pleased with yourself because she comments on how she can see right away that you are special.

The bad news is that self-appointed gurus like Limori become skilled at knowing exactly what temperature each and every person in the group needs to be cooking at to provide her with the greatest element of power, control and manipulation. Looking back I can see now that our guru knew exactly when to turn up or lower the heat that was directed at every one of us.

Suffice it to say that no one, frog or human, would knowingly subject themselves to the danger, lies, betrayal, manipulation, and life-shattering choices that become everyday occurrences once one is enmeshed in the hierarchy of an authoritarian leader. We join groups that turn out to be cults because we believe in the people in the group, we believe in the words that the leader is saying, and then slowly, slowly, degree by degree, we become used to the warmer temperatures. A skilled guru only turns the temperature up one more degree for each individual when that person has become perfectly comfortable at their current setting.

**
I can say for sure that the loss of the self that happens in a cult does occur very quietly. I did not scream and thrash and wail as the temperature was turned up in the pot the cult leader had me cooking in. I just quietly got used to the heat and kept my mouth shut any time I objected to how I was being treated.

Thankfully the return to oneself, while just as quiet as the loss, does happen. Regaining oneself after leaving a cult is a triumphant victory that may not garner any praise or a parade, but few personal victories are sweeter.

Share

Tagged Excerpts from the book, How Cults Work, Quotes

One Response to “Loss and gain”

  1. Georgia Says:

    Thank you for re-writing the chapter about the frog in boiling water. It is such a true description of the process. But what was so pleasing to me, was your last paragraph.The journey of healing and renewal back to oneself can and does happen as you say, though there may be rocks to stumble over, mud to step into and out of, it too is a slow but beautiful walk.

Leave a Comment